“Digital marketing” is a catchall term for the act of promoting services or products through media across varied digital channels. When this term is applied to the nonprofit sector, all that changes is that the services and products are designed to provide a societal benefit, but this is where things begin to become more complicated for nonprofits than their for-profit counterparts: It’s clear for a company like Amazon or Etsy that the goal is to sell more items through their site. A ‘win’ for a nonprofit’s website is to deepen an engagement with a set of stakeholders that leads to the long-term outcomes of the organization. While sometimes it may be as simple as driving more people to donate, it can become more difficult when dealing with driving awareness or behavior changes. This resource will help you to measure your impact using one of our favorite tools, the marketing funnel.
First things first: Let’s talk about #goals
Before we dive into how the impact marketing funnel can be applied to nonprofits, we have 3 questions for you to consider:
- Why does your organization have a website?
- Are your digital marketing and content marketing driving users to take next step actions?
- How do you know if your website is driving your intended offline impact?
These are difficult, but important questions that a nonprofit should be able to answer and, more importantly, measure.
Before drilling down on answering these questions, it is critical to have defined the larger impact measurement of outcomes for your nonprofit. Once the larger inputs, outputs, and outcomes of the organization have been defined they may be applied to the digital impact mapping process.
What is a marketing funnel?
A marketing funnel gives context and relative value to metrics and builds the larger narrative that they all build on each other to achieve your desired outcome. In this context, even social likes can be built into the narrative and not just seen as a vanity metric — assuming that it actually relates to the outcome your funnel points toward.
This funnel will also help your team realize the value of digital marketing, content, and communications because it puts them in context of the larger outcome. Also, the funnel presents opportunities for moving users between funnel steps, including A/B testing email request forms or donation pages or creating a content marketing strategy that drives conversions. For example, if you improve conversion to an email form by 200%, that doubles the effectiveness of the entire top of the funnel’s traffic metric without spending any money on ads.
Why digital impact mapping?
Digital impact mapping is the process of defining the exact set online behaviors that best reflect the type of action stakeholders need to take to eventually lead to the outcome of the organization. This map then serves as the bridge that helps a nonprofit cross the digital impact chasm that exists between what is done digitally and what happens in the world to create a societal benefit.
Picture a chasm. On one side there is the digital marketing, communication and content work your organization does on a daily basis, and on the other side are long-term societal benefits. While there are concrete outputs being created like emails and online content, how can you tell if this work is moving the needle on long-term impact?
The most common answer to this is usually some digital vanity metric like page views, sessions, likes or followers. A vanity metric is a vain number that may present the appearance of scale but ultimately holds low relevance to real impact. The key to avoiding these vanity metrics is to define predictive indicators that connect to real action.
“We are lost, but at least we’re making great time.” — Mario Morino, Leap of Reason
Without addressing the digital impact chasm a nonprofit can quickly drive in the wrong direction. Think of predictive indicators as the bridge across the chasm — the smoke and heat that indicate there is a fire. These indicators can then serve as a speedometer on the car with a GPS, helping you know if you are staying within the speed limit while traveling toward the destination.
How to use predictive indicators to define funnel stages
Digital indicators target the measurable elements of an organization’s online activities and outputs. The digital realm is awash in dashboards and big data, constantly churning out far more than can be synthesized.
“….information consumes the attention of its recipients. Hence a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention.” — Herbert Simon
It is easy to collect a bevy of vanity or high-level metrics like website users, social likes and reach, and content impressions. Every digital tool that an organization uses presents yet another dashboard, with a new set of metrics to chase. We must remember that for every metric that is added to the heap, the less attention there will be for any given metric – even the ones that matter. This makes the job of defining the right digital indicators critically important in dealing with the poverty of attention.
What indicators will move our marketing strategy forward?
The SMART acronym helps create some guard rails on the attributes of good digital indicators:
- Time Bound
And from here we can align these predictive digital indicators with the related marketing funnel stages. The question that frequently comes up once predictive metrics are defined is , “How often do we measure it?” The unsatisfying answer is: It depends on who you are and what your job role is. An organization should have a larger unifying metric such as the number children educated, stakeholders helped, or awareness threshold reached. This “North Star” metric can then be used to add context and relevance to supporting metrics that different departments feed into.
How to use the marketing funnel framework
The funnel of engagement is a perfect model to build that chain of relevance, the next question is how to use these predictive indicators. Whole Whale created an approach that helps plot the relevance to ease of measurability of the various metrics that can be tracked. This model helps the team acknowledge the assumptions and compromises that are being made when certain metrics are chosen over others because of the ability to measure them.
The blue line that divides the area will help you avoid measuring things simply because they are easier to measure leading to the “Streetlight Effect”. This effect leads us to look for observations where the light is rather than where the answers are. In the case of this model, the goal is to choose metrics in the top left area and avoid the lower right at all costs.
Once indicators are plotted by organizational department or function, it will be easier to look at them objectively and determine the frequency at which they should be measured. In general, the easier the metric is to measure, the easier it is to look at it on a weekly or monthly basis. This is a good starting point as long as the metric is a predictive indicator that leads to the North Star metric of the organization. Harder to measure indicators can be looked at on a quarterly/annual basis to make sure the larger outputs of the organization are aligned with the outcomes.
In the example above, we use Power Poetry, the largest online platform for teens and poetry. Their long term outcome is to increase the literacy rate in young people, and the predictive indicators that matter most are the number of poets and poems created in the system. An externality of this work would be decreased prison rates, as illiteracy is the most common factor among the incarcerated population. However, measuring this would be incredibly difficult, which is why it is in the bottom right and not actually as relevant to the core goal.
Measurability and funnel stages
As more metrics are added to this measurability framework, the relationship to the measurability of stages within your marketing funnel helps define how frequently you should be measuring your indicators. In this example with Words Without Borders, an organization that promotes cultural awareness through translation of international literature, measurability directly correlates to frequency.
Use this measurability framework as an exercise to plot your organization’s key metrics and have honest conversations about their true relevance to mission. Then come back and assess the measurability to determine where it should fit in frequency of measurement within your marketing funnel.
Dashboards and Feedback Loops
There are many tools that can be used to create dashboards and every web, social, and CRM has different versions and views of data. The key is to find the right way to bundle the metrics needed for each department and person depending on their job. Creating this dashboard through Google Analytics, Google Data Studio or a third party like Domo or SumAll is the first step.
Many teams stop at dashboard creation step, and assume just because they may have a live feed of data in the waiting area TV screen that the organization all set. Dashboards only become useful once they are adopted into the processes of the different departments in an organization. This can range from getting automatic delivery of dashboards to your email, or getting data texted to you. Ideally, key metrics and dashboards pulled from each stage of the marketing funnel are introduced into standing meetings and built into staff performance reporting structures.
The ability for key metrics to influence behavior within an organization depends on creating feedback loops. In the same way that a car’s speedometer influences how fast people drive when combined with speed limit signs, showing staff how their behavior influences key metrics positively or negatively will have a similar effect. This is the beginning of creating a data culture within your organization and moving users down that all-knowing marketing funnel.